Monday, May 22, 2006

India's new manufacturing mantra

The world's carmakers are to be given a novel way of keeping ahead of rivals: sending their competitors' vehicles to a $125m (£66.1m) engineering centre in India where they will be dismantled to reveal their technical secrets. Mahindra, an Indian industrial conglomerate, is building the "tear-down" in Chennai as part of a larger complex that, when finished early next year, will employ 1,000 engineers.
The initiative underlines the mix of ideas - a "service" approach to production, backed by a willingness to think globally - that sets India-based manufacturers apart from their rivals across Asia, and particularly China.
...Philippe Joubert, head of the power equipment division of Alstom, a French engineering company that has operations in both India and China, says the two countries' models for manufacturing are clearly distinct. "China is geared to mass production. India focuses on manufacturing backed up by software and high-level engineering."
Both countries have the advantage of low labour costs - which is invaluable in reducing the price of making standard goods - plus the potential of huge domestic markets over the next 20 years provided by their countries' 1bn-plus populations. But China is a long way ahead in the world's league table of manufacturing output, lying in third place behind the US and Japan, while India is 14th.
Yet India has an edge in the service aspects of manufacturing, say some observers. Once regarded as peripheral to the "core" task of production, these areas include design, development, links with suppliers and the ability to customise output to meet changes in demand patterns.
Now, though, the services elements are becoming more important as manufacturers seek more sophisticated links with suppliers and customers de-mand greater customisation in the finished product.
In many manufacturing companies, no more than one-fifth of employees are defined as manufacturing workers. The majority are doing jobs more properly categorised as service occupations. Sometimes - as in the case of pure "product originators" such as Nike, the clothing company, which outsources virtually all of its production - the proportion falls close to zero.
One reason for this is that manufacturers often turn to service as a defensive strategy to protect themselves from rivals muscling in on their territory.
Anita Woülfl of the Centre d'Etudes Prospectives et d'Informations Internationales, a Paris-based economics institute, says: "Manufacturers all over the world are increasingly interested in services as a way to make themselves more competitive and also to find new sources of growth."
The service activities in manufacturing span a range of tasks, from maintenance contracts to design work. Some of the costs of these are bundled inside the price of goods, while others are paid for separately (see right).
India's recent history puts it in a good position to exploit this shift, says Anand Sharma, president of TBM Consulting, a US-based manufacturing advisory group. The seeds of the country's prowess in manufacturing services were sown back in the 1990s, he says, when it became a world centre in software development and business process outsourcing (BPO), in which providers take over jobs such as payroll administration on behalf of customers in other countries.
Together, software development and BPO provide fast-expanding revenues for India-based companies of about $23bn a year, and account for 1.3m jobs. India's growth in this field - as in the service side of manufacturing generally - is boosted by its proficiency in English, the world's business language. Another attraction is the fact that the cost of employing engineers - essential to manufacturing services - is one-third to one-fifth lower in India than in industrialised nations such as the UK and the US.
"The BPO boom in India provided a core of expertise in software and a service-based approach to customers based around the world," says Mr Sharma. "It has led to an interest by manufacturers [in India] to add value to basic manufacturing through offering services."
Arvind Subramanian, an economist at the Washington-based International Monetary Fund, says India's ability to compete in this field is based on its focus on fairly small-scale manufacturing operations, aimed at turning out goods in small batches and with close consultation with customers - a prerequisite for a service-based approach. He adds that there is "no doubt" that India has a global competitive advantage when it comes to service-based manufacturing.
Some of the India-based companies pioneering the service model for manufacturing are foreign businesses whose products require complex software and vary greatly depending on customers' needs. Pradipta Sen, president of the India arm of Emerson, the US engineering company, says a "customer-facing" capability is a hallmark of Emerson's India-based operations.
Ravi Uppal, managing director for India at ABB, the Swiss-Swedish engineering group, says India has an advantage in products such as automation equipment for factories and electricity transmission systems - in other words, products that are defined by software variations."India is good at the softer skills involved with manufacturing. We can use these to integrate production with [software] engineering and move in the direction of tailored products," says Mr Uppal.
This move up the value chain is reflected in the make-up of the workforce. Only about 1,200 of ABB's 4,000 India-based employees work in factories. The rest hold positions in design, engineering, marketing and sales - roles that address the design and production of customer-specific products.
In making new kinds of control systems for electricity transmission, for instance, ABB's India arm is geared around answering the individual needs of its power company customers. Sigma Electric, a US company that has based most of its production in India, has also adopted a manufacturing approach based on swift changes in design, allowing it to respond more quickly to fluctuations in demand. The company - set up by India-born engineer Sajjan Agarwal - makes all its products in five low-cost India plants. It sells its goods predominantly to large US industrial groups such as General Electric and Delphi.
Mr Agarwal says: "We have 8,000 products in our catalogue and are flexible enough to make them in batches of as few as 100 at a time." Out of 1,200 employees, 200 are engineers - including a corps of 30 development staff who work on new products and whose numbers Mr Agarwal wants to double in the next five years.
If Indian manufacturers are to capitalise on the services model, links with international companies are vital. The Indian market for engineering goods remains relatively small, though it could expand considerably in the next decade if economic growth projections are met. While China's manufacturers have made their mark on the global economy mainly through exporting, Indians are doing far more to set up production centres outside their home country, and linking these to a "service" approach.
Mahindra & Mahindra, for instance, is setting up a global network of vehicle parts factories - linked to its production operations in India - that will make specialised components to order on behalf of large western carmakers. And Bharat Forge, a large India-based components manufacturer, is establishing plants in the UK, Germany and the US to supply customers in these markets.
...Baba Kalyarni, chairman of Bharat Forge, says the outward-looking approach - coupled with a way of looking at manufacturing as a combination of production and services - is critical for India's manufacturers. "What will give companies [in India] an edge is a combination of technology and service," he says.
India is acting as a laboratory for these ideas and is now starting to show how they operate in practice. The lessons that emerge will not be confined to its borders, however. The experience of manufacturers in formulating the right blend of production and service, and linking these to their far-flung customers' requirements, will be studied by manufacturers the world over.

text from financial times, london

1 comment:

Anonymous said...

keep up the good work
with more articles